Home

American Healthcare: The Challenge to Stay on Top

November 17, 2022
4:45 pm

The Healthcare Leadership Council hosted a webinar which highlighted the relationship between intellectual property (IP) and innovation, a linkage that is critically important in healthcare. The panel was comprised of:

  • Joe Allen, Executive Director of the Bayh-Dole Coalition
  • Eric Aaronson, Pfizer’s Chief Counsel for Corporate Affairs, Intellectual Property and Intellectual Property Enforcement Departments
  • Catherine Burch, Vice President of Innovation at ChristianaCare Health System
  • Paul Higgins, Vice President of Law, Head of Global IP Policy at Johnson & Johnson

The webinar was an open discussion covering the history and role of IP laws, as well as the importance of partnerships and collaboration in achieving new discoveries. It was acknowledged that not all that long ago the United States not the world’s global leader in life sciences, as it is today. The Bayh-Dole Act, enacted in 1980, decentralized technology from Washington bureaucracy and allowed the people creating biopharmaceutical and medical technology innovations to own and manage them, integrating incentives into the patent-and-licensing process and jumpstarting a renaissance in healthcare innovation.

The panelists agreed that the IP system encouraged investment in risk. A robust IP system provides two key benefits: (1) the assurance of intellectual property rights that are protected from bad actors who would diminish their value, and  (2) the creation of mechanism to transfer knowledge to those who can commercialize it for the greater public good. It enables collaboration between innovators, governments, universities, research partners, all of which are focused on exchanging information to speed up progress to finding solutions. Innovation is iterative and enables scientists to build off the discovery of others. Collaborations are key because it they enable to essential distribution of risk. It can require 10-15 years to develop a drug, cost upwards of $2.6 billion on average, and only about 10 percent of drugs evaluated in Phase 1 clinical trials are ever approved. Entities will not take on this level of risk without strong IP protections.

The pro-competitive nature of IP was also emphasized. Given that a drug or medicine may not be best option for every patient, having multiple solutions is important. Once the exclusivity period expires for a drug, it facilitates low-cost generic entry. There are those who like to pit the innovator versus generics, but it is really two sides of the same coin. To encourage new generics getting to market there must be support for strong IP systems, because the generic pipeline is the innovator pipeline.

The concept of march-in rights, a provision in the Bayh-Dole Act was also discussed. It was inserted to ensure that inventions didn’t sit dormant and were licensed to serve the public good; otherwise the government could “march in” and license them to entities who would move forward with production. Recently, there has been a push to use march-in rights to force price reductions for pharmaceuticals by shifting licensing from the current manufacturer to a company that could presumably make the drug cheaper. All petitions using this theory have been rejected by multiple administrations, because it is not what the Bayh-Dole authors intended. This would create a slippery slope in which holders of any intellectual property for which government funding played a role at some point in the process could have their license taken away. This would destabilize a system that has made the U.S. the technological innovation center of the world by discouraging investment in research and development.

Given the level of exchange of technologies that are required for the fast-paced collaboration and eventual production of the COVID-19 vaccine, none of the current vaccines would have occurred without an IP system that supported incentives and created an environment where information could be exchanged so that the iterative scientific process of discovery could work to the benefit everyone. Not only the discovery, but scaling the supply once a drug is approved requires researching manufacturing sites globally to find partners that are able to produce safe and effective vaccines to meet global demands. Every one of those partnerships rely on a sound and robust IP system.

74 Responses to “American Healthcare: The Challenge to Stay on Top”

  1. Abjekq Says:

    albuterol cost albuterol brand buy ventolin inhaler

  2. Djyqxp Says:

    tizanidine drug buy zanaflex without prescription buy tizanidine no prescription

  3. Neilqp Says:

    purchase deltasone without prescription buy deltasone online cheap generic deltasone 40mg

  4. Ymblry Says:

    order isotretinoin 20mg generic buy accutane 10mg pill buy absorica pill

  5. Tsoosf Says:

    order amoxil generic order amoxicillin 250mg pill amoxil generic

  6. Spckel Says:

    purchase ventolin inhalator albuterol online order buy albuterol 4mg pill

  7. Khadvv Says:

    azithromycin 500mg for sale buy azithromycin no prescription buy zithromax 250mg pills

  8. Hwqgvv Says:

    order generic augmentin 1000mg generic clavulanate augmentin 375mg canada

  9. Hjtfvl Says:

    brand omnacortil prednisolone 10mg pill buy cheap generic omnacortil

  10. Lzhfwh Says:

    synthroid cost levoxyl pill levothroid tablets

  11. Hvuqqy Says:

    order gabapentin 600mg without prescription gabapentin pill buy neurontin 600mg generic

  12. Dgaksl Says:

    clomid online buy buy serophene buy clomiphene 100mg online cheap

  13. Vjoqgl Says:

    buy lasix generic diuretic buy lasix 40mg generic cheap lasix 100mg

  14. Dufhcp Says:

    sildenafil 50mg cheap order sildenafil oral viagra 100mg

  15. Ljqxxm Says:

    order doxycycline buy doxycycline no prescription vibra-tabs over the counter

  16. Udhzob Says:

    buy semaglutide generic where can i buy rybelsus buy cheap generic semaglutide

  17. Wxbqhi Says:

    cost plaquenil order plaquenil pills order plaquenil 400mg for sale

  18. Ovltxu Says:

    triamcinolone 4mg pill order aristocort 4mg online triamcinolone 4mg for sale

  19. Qffsrr Says:

    cialis for men brand cialis 40mg cialis 40mg us

  20. Fedxpw Says:

    buy generic clarinex 5mg buy clarinex 5mg generic buy desloratadine no prescription

  21. Tlatpt Says:

    generic cenforce 50mg order cenforce cenforce 100mg without prescription

  22. Vvaemf Says:

    buy cheap generic claritin cost claritin 10mg order loratadine for sale

  23. Cqaryh Says:

    buy chloroquine generic aralen brand cheap chloroquine 250mg

  24. Xzvkie Says:

    cost dapoxetine buy priligy 30mg generic buy cytotec without prescription

  25. Qazmii Says:

    xenical usa purchase diltiazem sale diltiazem 180mg for sale

  26. Xeyehr Says:

    glucophage 500mg us buy metformin generic glucophage 500mg price

  27. Mlnpom Says:

    zovirax 400mg ca order zovirax 400mg online cheap buy generic allopurinol

  28. Ingqhr Says:

    norvasc tablet where can i buy amlodipine purchase amlodipine for sale

  29. Krlfds Says:

    buy generic crestor for sale zetia 10mg tablet zetia 10mg over the counter

  30. Csswfc Says:

    buy lisinopril pill buy zestril 5mg generic zestril 10mg for sale

  31. Hpeytt Says:

    buy generic motilium over the counter cheap domperidone 10mg brand tetracycline

  32. Rmxdyv Says:

    buy prilosec 10mg without prescription omeprazole 10mg for sale buy prilosec without prescription

  33. Qqzknp Says:

    cyclobenzaprine order online flexeril without prescription order baclofen 10mg pills

  34. Kpzveg Says:

    order metoprolol 50mg online cheap brand lopressor 50mg buy metoprolol 100mg

  35. Kynvml Says:

    toradol buy online colcrys online order colchicine 0.5mg generic

  36. Zdnfxu Says:

    purchase tenormin pill purchase atenolol without prescription order atenolol 50mg online

  37. Ycyjvb Says:

    methylprednisolone australia where to buy methylprednisolone without a prescription methylprednisolone 16 mg over counter

  38. Qkxtjb Says:

    inderal pill buy inderal no prescription plavix 75mg generic

  39. Bzdlpi Says:

    helpwithassignment help writing a research paper do my research paper

  40. Yrxgcg Says:

    buy methotrexate no prescription purchase warfarin pill cheap warfarin 2mg

  41. Bajdsl Says:

    how to get metoclopramide without a prescription buy metoclopramide 10mg sale purchase hyzaar online

  42. Zpofdy Says:

    buy mobic 7.5mg pills celebrex pill oral celecoxib 200mg

  43. Wqcuqp Says:

    tamsulosin 0.2mg drug celecoxib usa purchase celebrex online cheap

  44. Nbkeue Says:

    buy esomeprazole pill order esomeprazole 40mg sale topiramate 200mg sale

  45. Esxwfu Says:

    sumatriptan 25mg pills brand imitrex buy levaquin 250mg

  46. Sbgpkx Says:

    order zofran online cheap ondansetron cheap order aldactone pills

  47. Kdlvil Says:

    avodart 0.5mg canada ranitidine order online zantac price

  48. Kdvnjq Says:

    simvastatin 10mg brand order zocor 20mg valtrex 500mg pills

  49. Xgjffu Says:

    buy ampicillin online cost acticlate buy amoxil cheap

  50. Oftkyr Says:

    order generic finasteride 5mg diflucan 200mg oral diflucan 200mg generic

  51. Favuww Says:

    ciprofloxacin 1000mg canada – amoxiclav drug augmentin 625mg ca

  52. Liwooh Says:

    ciprofloxacin 1000mg generic – cheap bactrim 480mg augmentin pills

  53. Okixnx Says:

    flagyl 400mg sale – amoxicillin over the counter buy zithromax generic

  54. Evaxko Says:

    ciplox 500mg generic – buy ciplox 500 mg for sale buy erythromycin 500mg for sale

  55. Ieelrc Says:

    order valacyclovir 1000mg sale – acyclovir for sale order zovirax for sale

  56. Brueqa Says:

    ivermectin 12 mg otc – ceftin oral tetracycline online

  57. Vzztzl Says:

    flagyl usa – cleocin pills azithromycin 500mg pill

  58. Uzjcbj Says:

    furosemide 40mg ca – furosemide pills captopril us

  59. Ftsjls Says:

    buy acillin pills for sale amoxicillin medication order amoxil pills

  60. Vzskjy Says:

    retrovir 300 mg usa – allopurinol over the counter zyloprim over the counter

  61. Pmevpz Says:

    buy metformin generic – order metformin sale lincocin 500mg cheap

  62. Emimfs Says:

    buy seroquel sale – eskalith price buy generic eskalith online

  63. Wtqwjq Says:

    clozaril sale – quinapril price order famotidine 40mg for sale

  64. Ywkyhw Says:

    hydroxyzine generic – order amitriptyline generic buy generic amitriptyline for sale

  65. Xjbhsw Says:

    anafranil 50mg pills – buy generic sinequan for sale doxepin 25mg ca

  66. Nhgfpm Says:

    cheap amoxicillin online – where can i buy erythromycin purchase cipro online

  67. Nkthgw Says:

    cost augmentin 1000mg – buy ciprofloxacin 1000mg pills cipro us

  68. Uegqse Says:

    cost cleocin 300mg – order doxycycline sale chloramphenicol over the counter

  69. Faumag Says:

    zithromax drug – azithromycin 500mg pill buy ciprofloxacin 500 mg pills

  70. Pzjtzn Says:

    buy generic ventolin online – albuterol drug theo-24 Cr price

  71. Ejfgcc Says:

    stromectol 2mg online – levofloxacin without prescription buy cefaclor 500mg generic

  72. Dgahjz Says:

    buy cheap clarinex – purchase flixotide generic buy albuterol generic

  73. Zbzsvq Says:

    order glyburide 2.5mg online – glipizide ca forxiga 10 mg without prescription

  74. Kvfuan Says:

    repaglinide medication – how to get empagliflozin without a prescription empagliflozin pill

Leave a Reply