Home

Pinocchioizing the Medicare debate

July 01, 2013
9:55 am

Even if we can’t find a way to eliminate ‘Mediscare’ political tactics altogether, shouldn’t we be able to at least limit retiree-scaring strategies to election years?

This weekend, Glenn Kessler, the Washington Post’s fact checker, pointed out that even odd-numbered years are open season for frightening seniors with outrageously misleading hyperbole.  Kessler spotlighted a television ad sponsored by two political action committees, Patriot Majority USA and Senate Majority PAC, aimed at Congressman Tom Cotton (R-AR).  The video accuses Cotton of supporting a plan that would “essentially end Medicare” and cost some seniors more than $6000 a year.

This ad is, of course, absolute nonsense that has been repeated — and discredited — many times before.  Kessler, in fact, gave it his highest (or is it lowest) rating of “four pinocchios,” meaning it is highly deceptive messaging.

The two PAC groups are tying Cotton to an early iteration, since revised, of Congressman Paul Ryan’s (R-WI) Medicare reform plan.  That plan, of course, wouldn’t end Medicare, but rather open the program up to participation by private health plans.  And since the early Ryan version that the ad is referencing, the proposal has been revised to give seniors the option of remaining in conventional fee-for-service Medicare instead of opting for the private choice-and-competition plan.

Patriot Majority PAC and Senate Majority PAC know all of this, of course, but having a legitimate and necessary debate over Medicare’s future takes a back seat to using the program as a cudgel to pound down a political opponent’s approval numbers.

I don’t know if Congressman Cotton will be hurt by this ad but, regardless, he isn’t among the biggest losers here.  Those would be the Arkansas voters who are being led to believe something that simply isn’t true, and current and future Medicare beneficiaries who need and deserve a genuine discussion over how to improve and sustain the program.

Mediscare tactics are deplorable enough in election years, but can’t we at least have one year out of every two in which we can have an honest conversation about the issue?

97 Responses to “Pinocchioizing the Medicare debate”

  1. Bslphm Says:

    ventolin 2mg us ventolin 4mg brand order albuterol 4mg generic

  2. Fkseyr Says:

    buy asthma pills onlin order albuterol for sale brand albuterol

  3. Zpgetu Says:

    tizanidine drug buy zanaflex medication tizanidine online order

  4. Avtzns Says:

    buy deltasone 20mg generic buy prednisone 10mg prednisone pills

  5. Jspxba Says:

    order isotretinoin 40mg without prescription purchase accutane pill isotretinoin buy online

  6. Pyppyj Says:

    albuterol 2mg over the counter brand ventolin order ventolin 2mg inhaler

  7. Nhfmnd Says:

    order albuterol inhalator generic purchase albuterol generic buy generic albuterol

  8. Vhltcn Says:

    amoxil 1000mg without prescription amoxil 1000mg without prescription buy amoxil generic

  9. Jrbbly Says:

    buy amoxiclav online cheap oral amoxiclav augmentin order

  10. Kohezj Says:

    order amoxiclav pill amoxiclav over the counter clavulanate brand

  11. Wxxlrw Says:

    azithromycin 500mg cost purchase zithromax sale zithromax order online

  12. Gbywuq Says:

    order generic synthroid cost synthroid 150mcg oral levoxyl

  13. Inwbli Says:

    buy cheap levothyroxine levoxyl for sale synthroid 75mcg without prescription

  14. Kczrab Says:

    order prednisolone 20mg omnacortil pills buy omnacortil 20mg online

  15. Moitae Says:

    order clomid sale order clomid 50mg online cheap buy clomiphene generic

  16. Halxgs Says:

    order clomid 100mg online cheap buy clomiphene sale buy clomid 50mg pill

  17. Tyferw Says:

    buy generic gabapentin cheap neurontin how to buy gabapentin

  18. Lfmmvt Says:

    purchase furosemide generic buy furosemide no prescription generic lasix 100mg

  19. Kkinav Says:

    order sildenafil 50mg for sale order viagra online cheap viagra 100mg cost

  20. Pypdai Says:

    sildenafil us viagra overnight shipping usa cheapest viagra

  21. Qwvhgu Says:

    doxycycline medication purchase monodox without prescription buy doxycycline without a prescription

  22. Wukddv Says:

    buy semaglutide 14mg generic semaglutide cost semaglutide price

  23. Tithfe Says:

    semaglutide canada semaglutide 14 mg sale buy semaglutide pill

  24. Oizeoa Says:

    play poker online real money slot online play online casino real money

  25. Reojkt Says:

    order aristocort 4mg pills purchase triamcinolone online cheap how to buy triamcinolone

  26. Ihqkcl Says:

    order tadalafil 20mg for sale buy cialis sale buy cialis sale

  27. Xnrjlv Says:

    order cialis generic cialis online canada cialis without prescription

  28. Ovzurg Says:

    order desloratadine sale buy clarinex 5mg sale buy clarinex 5mg for sale

  29. Vlsjcp Says:

    order cenforce 50mg generic buy cenforce 100mg without prescription cenforce price

  30. Kvmgvr Says:

    where can i buy cenforce buy cenforce 100mg pill buy cenforce pills

  31. Btuicg Says:

    buy claritin 10mg online cheap claritin canada claritin 10mg brand

  32. Hgotrf Says:

    aralen 250mg pill buy aralen for sale buy generic aralen

  33. Rvuchx Says:

    buy chloroquine 250mg pill buy aralen without prescription purchase chloroquine generic

  34. Rcsuoh Says:

    how to buy glucophage glucophage 1000mg tablet purchase glycomet pills

  35. Nhxtxa Says:

    cost metformin 500mg buy glucophage generic metformin 500mg uk

  36. Bljghv Says:

    buy orlistat pills buy diltiazem 180mg generic order diltiazem generic

  37. Kcwubj Says:

    atorvastatin 10mg sale atorvastatin 10mg pills buy atorvastatin cheap

  38. Uvasbc Says:

    order atorvastatin 80mg lipitor 80mg oral atorvastatin 80mg uk

  39. Cmshyg Says:

    generic acyclovir 400mg order zyloprim generic allopurinol 300mg over the counter

  40. Sjentl Says:

    oral amlodipine 10mg purchase norvasc pill buy amlodipine 5mg generic

  41. Ouhupx Says:

    order amlodipine pill buy generic norvasc 10mg amlodipine 5mg without prescription

  42. Bmmpmx Says:

    oral rosuvastatin zetia 10mg pill buy zetia medication

  43. Ksserw Says:

    purchase prinivil generic buy lisinopril 10mg online cheap buy zestril 10mg pills

  44. Rwdect Says:

    buy zestril 5mg sale buy lisinopril 2.5mg for sale lisinopril 10mg pill

  45. Wudyeb Says:

    purchase domperidone generic buy motilium generic buy generic tetracycline 500mg

  46. Olxcbz Says:

    omeprazole 20mg pills order prilosec without prescription brand prilosec

  47. Efpwbe Says:

    omeprazole 10mg us omeprazole brand omeprazole price

  48. Hpdzhx Says:

    order cyclobenzaprine 15mg without prescription flexeril 15mg oral baclofen 25mg uk

  49. Fygdss Says:

    order metoprolol 50mg generic lopressor 50mg drug order metoprolol for sale

  50. Donauf Says:

    order lopressor 100mg sale order metoprolol generic lopressor 50mg brand

  51. Tzbrzm Says:

    ketorolac us buy colcrys generic colchicine medication

  52. Guimgh Says:

    atenolol 100mg ca tenormin us buy atenolol 50mg online cheap

  53. Gplfmd Says:

    oral atenolol 50mg buy atenolol paypal tenormin 50mg oral

  54. Afgeqg Says:

    methylprednisolone 8mg pills generic medrol online methylprednisolone canada

  55. Htdmlb Says:

    depo-medrol pills canada buy medrol without prescription buy depo-medrol uk

  56. Dobxhd Says:

    inderal price plavix 75mg tablet plavix sale

  57. Rvtbtx Says:

    pay for essays i need a paper written for me buy essay paper

  58. Qcqrwh Says:

    i need a paper written for me best essay writing websites online assignment help

  59. Lyjoqh Says:

    buy methotrexate pills for sale how to get methotrexate without a prescription coumadin 5mg us

  60. Njpnow Says:

    order meloxicam for sale celebrex 200mg drug purchase celebrex online cheap

  61. Fvvdjj Says:

    order meloxicam pills celebrex generic purchase celebrex sale

  62. Tkxala Says:

    reglan price maxolon brand buy losartan 25mg sale

  63. Ucofhn Says:

    esomeprazole online nexium 40mg cheap buy topamax 100mg generic

  64. Pdavng Says:

    buy flomax medication order celecoxib online celecoxib usa

  65. Ouiwti Says:

    purchase tamsulosin for sale buy celecoxib 100mg generic order celebrex

  66. Tigfub Says:

    buy ondansetron 8mg pill order aldactone 100mg online order spironolactone 100mg generic

  67. Bldgfw Says:

    cheap zofran buy spironolactone generic buy generic aldactone 100mg

  68. Nxnjxk Says:

    buy generic imitrex 50mg imitrex ca levaquin 250mg over the counter

  69. Akbepe Says:

    dutasteride medication buy generic zantac brand zantac

  70. Lnqaqr Says:

    purchase simvastatin buy valacyclovir online cheap order valacyclovir 1000mg generic

  71. Rsndbi Says:

    zocor 10mg sale cost valacyclovir 500mg valacyclovir 500mg canada

  72. Zcuqwh Says:

    generic ampicillin purchase penicillin cheap amoxil for sale

  73. Ttohjz Says:

    order propecia 1mg generic order generic diflucan 100mg buy fluconazole tablets

  74. Ekmsfv Says:

    purchase propecia pills generic propecia 1mg buy generic fluconazole over the counter

  75. Qzykjp Says:

    baycip where to buy – order bactrim 480mg sale order augmentin for sale

  76. Uydumc Says:

    buy cipro 1000mg generic – amoxiclav generic order augmentin 625mg pill

  77. Hqlmxz Says:

    cipro 500mg ca – buy ethambutol 1000mg online cheap buy generic clavulanate

  78. Kunxic Says:

    order ciprofloxacin 1000mg sale – buy myambutol 600mg sale augmentin 625mg uk

  79. Whupzm Says:

    cheap ciprofloxacin 500 mg – erythromycin 250mg ca erythromycin 250mg pills

  80. Aqtmia Says:

    order ciplox 500 mg online cheap – cheap ciprofloxacin erythromycin 250mg brand

  81. Xkuhni Says:

    flagyl 200mg pills – flagyl pills zithromax over the counter

  82. Fyklvf Says:

    order metronidazole sale – order generic azithromycin order azithromycin 500mg generic

  83. Vsjzjx Says:

    stromectol for humans for sale – order cefixime pills sumycin 500mg usa

  84. Fqvtai Says:

    ivermectin drug – purchase amoxiclav pill buy generic sumycin 250mg

  85. Dkdqsk Says:

    order valtrex 500mg generic – order generic valacyclovir 500mg acyclovir 400mg pills

  86. Ciycaz Says:

    order valacyclovir 500mg for sale – diltiazem medication zovirax 400mg ca

  87. Bczfhr Says:

    ampicillin medication penicillin price buy amoxicillin pills for sale

  88. Yiored Says:

    buy metronidazole generic – buy cefaclor 250mg pill how to get azithromycin without a prescription

  89. Gdazcz Says:

    order flagyl 400mg online cheap – buy amoxicillin cheap azithromycin 500mg

  90. Ddbeym Says:

    furosemide 40mg cost – purchase medex online buy generic captopril

  91. Sryahk Says:

    lasix drug – buy generic capoten over the counter capoten order

  92. Zsuflb Says:

    buy generic glucophage 1000mg – order generic bactrim 960mg lincocin ca

  93. Ijqfek Says:

    oral glycomet 1000mg – brand combivir lincocin us

  94. Shirnx Says:

    where can i buy zidovudine – buy zyloprim 300mg online cheap

  95. Dqdoho Says:

    zidovudine ca – allopurinol 100mg pill

  96. Pnkyci Says:

    buy clozapine 50mg – order altace 10mg pills buy pepcid 40mg for sale

  97. Auzoel Says:

    buy clozaril generic – perindopril pills pepcid 40mg us

Leave a Reply