Home

The Ramifications of an Unwise Tax

February 07, 2012
3:37 pm

Even before its implementation, for which the Internal Revenue Service issued regulations last Friday, the medical device tax is already taking a heavy toll.

Late last year, a major device manufacturer, Stryker (a Healthcare Leadership Council member) announced that it was reducing its workforce by five percent to prepare for the financial hit that comes with the new 2.3 percent excise tax.  Similarly, another device maker, Covidien, said it would lay off 200 workers in the United States and move some of its production to Costa Rica and Mexico – again, to compensate for this new tax created as part of the Affordable Care Act.

So, the tally thus far is hundreds of jobs lost to a tax that hasn’t even taken effect yet.  The question is, how much more damage needs to be done before Congress takes corrective action.

The logic behind the medical device tax – which is a 2.3 percent tax on revenues, not profits – has always been severely flawed.  Device manufacturers, tax proponents said, would not be hurt because the money lost to increased taxes would be recouped from the millions of additional Americans acquiring health insurance when health reform takes full effect in 2014 and a commensurate increase in health services utilization.

That argument, though, doesn’t hold up against even casual scrutiny.  The vast majority of newly insured citizens will be the young, healthy ‘invincibles’ who have heretofore elected to bypass health coverage.  From this population group, there won’t be a heavy demand for coronary stents or artificial hips.  In fact, most medical devices are used in acute care settings, where health providers are already required to provide care for the uninsured. 

There is hope on the horizon.  Representative Erik Paulsen (R-MN) has gained over 225 cosponsors – a majority of the House of Representatives – for his legislation to repeal the device tax, and he has indicated that he has the word of the congressional leadership that his measure will be brought to a vote early this year.

The Paulsen bill should be enacted by the House, and the Senate should swiftly follow suit, before more jobs are lost to a tax that doesn’t even possess an acceptable rationale.

63 Responses to “The Ramifications of an Unwise Tax”

  1. Sdkque Says:

    generic asthma pills albuterol 2mg oral how to get albuterol without a prescription

  2. Drrnwp Says:

    buy tizanidine 2mg buy zanaflex generic buy zanaflex without prescription

  3. Rqickr Says:

    deltasone brand buy deltasone 5mg without prescription deltasone price

  4. Efwgpg Says:

    accutane usa purchase isotretinoin order isotretinoin 20mg

  5. Chofmp Says:

    ventolin without prescription albuterol medication buy generic albuterol inhalator

  6. Dbcwrq Says:

    order amoxicillin 1000mg sale buy amoxil generic amoxicillin us

  7. Gyprsh Says:

    brand amoxiclav amoxiclav drug augmentin 375mg uk

  8. Gqqkpx Says:

    azithromycin for sale online how to get azithromycin without a prescription zithromax 500mg for sale

  9. Qgisdc Says:

    purchase levothyroxine without prescription synthroid 100mcg brand levothroid pill

  10. Awmten Says:

    buy prednisolone 20mg pills buy omnacortil 20mg online buy omnacortil 5mg without prescription

  11. Mtdzon Says:

    serophene online order clomid 50mg generic serophene medication

  12. Xohaoi Says:

    buy neurontin 800mg generic buy neurontin 600mg generic gabapentin 100mg

  13. Gtfsgs Says:

    furosemide 40mg brand buy lasix 40mg generic furosemide medication

  14. Mjeeik Says:

    viagra ca sildenafil without prescription free shipping viagra

  15. Yhnrgp Says:

    monodox us order vibra-tabs online cheap doxycycline 100mg pills

  16. Spexje Says:

    rybelsus 14 mg for sale semaglutide 14 mg for sale order rybelsus pills

  17. Vnsuwc Says:

    triamcinolone 10mg generic triamcinolone 10mg over the counter aristocort 4mg ca

  18. Mbtwhh Says:

    cialis pills 40mg purchase tadalafil without prescription cialis 20mg pills

  19. Suvbfo Says:

    clarinex where to buy generic clarinex 5mg purchase clarinex sale

  20. Fhvcom Says:

    cenforce 50mg brand purchase cenforce for sale buy cenforce medication

  21. Rauqbv Says:

    buy claritin cheap buy loratadine generic buy claritin online cheap

  22. Rnlcwj Says:

    order chloroquine online how to get chloroquine without a prescription generic aralen

  23. Lpjxmn Says:

    cost priligy 30mg order priligy pill generic cytotec

  24. Nkuyjy Says:

    buy glycomet generic metformin 500mg canada metformin 1000mg oral

  25. Nbjjaw Says:

    glycomet medication order glycomet 1000mg pill glycomet 500mg canada

  26. Tbtfoq Says:

    xenical 120mg pills buy orlistat 120mg sale diltiazem 180mg cheap

  27. Hqzqvn Says:

    order lipitor 20mg online atorvastatin 20mg brand buy lipitor 20mg pills

  28. Reltcn Says:

    norvasc oral amlodipine pills order norvasc pills

  29. Wpdret Says:

    order acyclovir 800mg online cheap cost zyloprim 100mg order zyloprim generic

  30. Jdhutc Says:

    order lisinopril 5mg online cost lisinopril buy zestril generic

  31. Dblatw Says:

    order rosuvastatin 10mg pills order crestor generic where to buy ezetimibe without a prescription

  32. Bijepe Says:

    omeprazole price order omeprazole 20mg prilosec without prescription

  33. Ggkcwf Says:

    buy domperidone no prescription domperidone pills tetracycline over the counter

  34. Jjzblo Says:

    metoprolol 50mg pill lopressor 50mg sale lopressor 100mg pill

  35. Kmxsog Says:

    buy flexeril sale flexeril 15mg drug ozobax online order

  36. Fbrrbw Says:

    buy toradol online colchicine oral buy gloperba generic

  37. Tfxfqz Says:

    atenolol 100mg cheap buy cheap generic atenolol buy generic atenolol

  38. Kxrnwk Says:

    methylprednisolone 16 mg over counter purchase depo-medrol generic buy depo-medrol

  39. Dgwaxp Says:

    order inderal 10mg generic buy clopidogrel 75mg pills clopidogrel 75mg cheap

  40. Kvthdu Says:

    buy essay now buy a dissertation pay for dissertation

  41. Cajckf Says:

    buy methotrexate 2.5mg online warfarin 2mg pills order generic coumadin

  42. Fjvqdh Says:

    order generic mobic 7.5mg celecoxib cost oral celecoxib

  43. Adwurv Says:

    brand metoclopramide 10mg buy losartan 50mg generic order losartan for sale

  44. Brlxbj Says:

    purchase nexium topiramate cheap cost topiramate 200mg

  45. Gkywvi Says:

    tamsulosin 0.4mg cost tamsulosin for sale online celecoxib 200mg sale

  46. Azalbs Says:

    order zofran buy cheap generic spironolactone spironolactone 25mg us

  47. Nzlsot Says:

    sumatriptan 50mg canada levaquin for sale levofloxacin without prescription

  48. Nwtqcs Says:

    buy zocor online buy valtrex 500mg sale buy valtrex 500mg generic

  49. Rosuao Says:

    purchase dutasteride pill ranitidine 300mg oral oral zantac 150mg

  50. Iukmjy Says:

    buy acillin tablets vibra-tabs online order amoxicillin generic

  51. Unqrep Says:

    proscar oral buy forcan cheap buy diflucan online cheap

  52. Lbeueh Says:

    baycip online – myambutol ca where can i buy augmentin

  53. Anawqq Says:

    buy ciprofloxacin 1000mg generic – buy cheap generic septra oral amoxiclav

  54. Rerbzx Says:

    buy ciplox 500mg online cheap – erythromycin 500mg cost erythromycin 250mg canada

  55. Tvsvuh Says:

    buy metronidazole without a prescription – purchase amoxicillin online cheap azithromycin 500mg drug

  56. Nvvazu Says:

    stromectol 6mg online – order aczone without prescription tetracycline order

  57. Oulzrk Says:

    where can i buy valtrex – zovirax 400mg cost cost acyclovir

  58. Rhcryl Says:

    buy generic acillin for sale amoxicillin order online buy amoxicillin without prescription

  59. Sylnnd Says:

    how to buy metronidazole – generic cefaclor 250mg zithromax 250mg cost

  60. Hszkoo Says:

    lasix usa – buy generic warfarin for sale captopril 25mg canada

  61. Grbzaz Says:

    buy glucophage sale – glycomet 1000mg tablet purchase lincomycin generic

  62. Knpjnt Says:

    where can i buy cheap retrovir – epivir 100mg uk zyloprim 300mg without prescription

  63. Gffpre Says:

    clozaril 100mg uk – amaryl 1mg usa order famotidine

Leave a Reply