Home

The Danger of Information without Context

January 24, 2012
3:40 pm

If you’ve ever watched the movie “The Sixth Sense,” you see what a talented director and writer can accomplish by withholding critical information from the audience.  In that movie (and, no, I’m not going to spoil it if you haven’t seen it), M. Night Shyamalan holds back an essential fact about Bruce Willis’s main character until the very end of the film.  When that fact is revealed, it changes the entire context of what we thought we knew about the story.

What works well, though, in the cinema isn’t necessarily a sound methodology when it comes to public policy matters that affect lives.  Transparency is public matters is virtually always a good thing, but when the practice of transparency reveals facts without context, it can be counterproductive.

Dr. Thomas Stossel, a professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, discussed this issue in a Wall Street Journal op-ed this week, “Who Paid For Your Doctor’s Bagel?” In his op-ed piece, he discusses the Physicians Payment Sunshine Act, a new law that will require medical innovation companies to disclose any transfer of value to physicians.  The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has recently issued draft guidelines for implementation of the new law.

Again, in principle, this type of transparency is a good thing.   But when the new law results in a list of consulting fees and other payments made by pharmaceutical and medical device companies to physicians, there will be a piece of the puzzle still missing.  What is the purpose of that exchange beyond a minimalist bureaucratic definition such as “consulting fee?”  What was the impact for patients and for the current and future practice of healthcare?  Without this context, negative inferences can be made about any exchange of value.

As Stossel wrote in the Journal, “The media already exploit disclosures….to demean physicians compensated by royalties from useful inventions that they license to companies, or who were paid consulting fees for advice concerning the optimal use of products, or for educating other physicians about products.”

The fact is that collaborations between physicians and industry have led to some of the most important medical breakthroughs of the last several decades.  Physicians help guide industry on how to make new innovations beneficial for patients.  Companies train physicians on the optimal use of new drugs and devices.  This sharing of knowledge is essential to the advancement of healthcare.

We’ll be discussing this issue in greater detail in the months ahead.  HLC launched an initiative called the National Dialogue for Healthcare Innovation and, through this effort, multiple organization representing healthcare providers, health industry sectors, academia and patients have been developing a consensus set of principles to help guide future physician-industry collaborations.  More to come.

63 Responses to “The Danger of Information without Context”

  1. Odzkya Says:

    purchase albuterol inhalator without prescription albuterol pills albuterol 4mg tablet

  2. Ofsrkb Says:

    buy tizanidine for sale how to buy zanaflex buy tizanidine 2mg generic

  3. Qfcmip Says:

    prednisone 20mg over the counter order deltasone generic buy generic deltasone 10mg

  4. Yymmyp Says:

    order generic accutane 20mg accutane order online order isotretinoin 20mg generic

  5. Orwgsi Says:

    albuterol 4mg price ventolin 4mg cheap order albuterol generic

  6. Mtgmop Says:

    amoxicillin drug buy amoxicillin for sale buy amoxil 250mg

  7. Oricoo Says:

    augmentin ca augmentin 625mg pill buy clavulanate for sale

  8. Vofsia Says:

    zithromax online buy azithromycin 500mg brand buy generic azithromycin

  9. Hehmqc Says:

    buy synthroid 150mcg for sale levothyroxine canada levothyroxine price

  10. Ifztfz Says:

    cheap prednisolone generic buy prednisolone generic purchase prednisolone generic

  11. Cuhxwt Says:

    clomiphene 50mg cheap serophene order online generic clomid 50mg

  12. Mahlxm Says:

    how to get gabapentin without a prescription cheap gabapentin pills oral gabapentin

  13. Zipflr Says:

    purchase furosemide for sale generic lasix 100mg buy furosemide 100mg online cheap

  14. Hqugvo Says:

    sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription sildenafil 100mg pills for sale us viagra

  15. Xvwfth Says:

    order doxycycline 200mg online cheap buy vibra-tabs for sale order acticlate generic

  16. Nfepfk Says:

    rybelsus 14mg usa order rybelsus 14mg for sale oral rybelsus 14 mg

  17. Jwdice Says:

    generic hydroxychloroquine buy generic hydroxychloroquine for sale plaquenil 200mg usa

  18. Rzwzem Says:

    triamcinolone 4mg brand purchase aristocort pill buy aristocort tablets

  19. Fegiob Says:

    purchase cialis pill tadalafil 5mg without prescription tadalafil 40mg oral

  20. Qgytea Says:

    clarinex 5mg pills purchase clarinex without prescription cost clarinex 5mg

  21. Nhuawp Says:

    order cenforce 100mg online cenforce us order cenforce 100mg pill

  22. Samqhh Says:

    order loratadine sale claritin 10mg oral order loratadine without prescription

  23. Mmxanm Says:

    buy generic aralen buy chloroquine cheap buy chloroquine paypal

  24. Gglbke Says:

    priligy uk buy dapoxetine 60mg online misoprostol for sale

  25. Cewwfg Says:

    glycomet 1000mg over the counter buy glycomet 1000mg generic glycomet 500mg without prescription

  26. Pygmkc Says:

    xenical cheap buy generic diltiazem 180mg diltiazem for sale online

  27. Wbsxbp Says:

    norvasc us buy amlodipine 10mg generic order norvasc

  28. Wyoxnm Says:

    buy acyclovir 800mg online cheap brand zovirax 800mg buy generic allopurinol online

  29. Tcsimu Says:

    buy generic rosuvastatin over the counter purchase ezetimibe without prescription how to buy zetia

  30. Qvvcbc Says:

    buy zestril pills for sale generic zestril 10mg zestril 10mg canada

  31. Cahlsb Says:

    cost domperidone 10mg purchase sumycin without prescription buy sumycin 250mg generic

  32. Zuljgq Says:

    cost prilosec omeprazole usa prilosec 20mg uk

  33. Jfwesr Says:

    buy cyclobenzaprine no prescription flexeril 15mg uk buy baclofen 10mg online cheap

  34. Lmevvf Says:

    order lopressor 100mg sale metoprolol 100mg over the counter buy metoprolol 100mg online cheap

  35. Swujcf Says:

    ketorolac sale order colcrys sale cost colchicine

  36. Vyuqhp Says:

    order tenormin 100mg online cheap order atenolol sale generic tenormin

  37. Ovwpnd Says:

    medrol 16 mg tablet medrol 4 mg pills methylprednisolone 8mg without prescription

  38. Ffqmem Says:

    buy inderal tablets purchase plavix online cheap plavix 75mg pills

  39. Qzpdhs Says:

    do my research paper write research paper college essay assistance

  40. Gqtdnm Says:

    methotrexate 5mg sale methotrexate order where can i buy coumadin

  41. Guxvvr Says:

    meloxicam 15mg tablet mobic over the counter order celecoxib 100mg online

  42. Atsawo Says:

    how to get maxolon without a prescription purchase maxolon without prescription how to get losartan without a prescription

  43. Tjrrwf Says:

    purchase tamsulosin without prescription buy generic celebrex 200mg order celebrex 100mg pill

  44. Ecxuea Says:

    buy esomeprazole without a prescription buy topamax 200mg topamax 100mg ca

  45. Mrhkro Says:

    order zofran 4mg without prescription spironolactone 100mg ca aldactone 25mg price

  46. Cbweqd Says:

    order sumatriptan 25mg without prescription levaquin 250mg canada levofloxacin medication

  47. Xjxmqd Says:

    buy zocor paypal simvastatin brand generic valacyclovir

  48. Sjgklh Says:

    buy dutasteride without a prescription generic zantac order ranitidine 300mg for sale

  49. Lnayox Says:

    order buy generic ampicillin online order amoxil pills

  50. Lengua Says:

    where can i buy propecia proscar ca fluconazole 200mg pill

  51. Wgnqrq Says:

    how to get baycip without a prescription – cipro 1000mg us purchase amoxiclav pill

  52. Jystsj Says:

    buy cipro 500mg online – buy amoxiclav generic buy generic clavulanate

  53. Xgudsz Says:

    buy ciplox 500mg online cheap – doryx usa buy erythromycin pills for sale

  54. Ceqicz Says:

    where to buy flagyl without a prescription – cleocin where to buy zithromax buy online

  55. Rqiznd Says:

    stromectol online canada – sumycin where to buy tetracycline over the counter

  56. Qgzhvf Says:

    india ivermectin – buy generic tetracycline online oral tetracycline

  57. Ydylps Says:

    valtrex 1000mg brand – zovirax usa buy zovirax 400mg pills

  58. Djgciz Says:

    where can i buy ampicillin purchase amoxil generic cheap amoxicillin generic

  59. Klbidu Says:

    buy flagyl 200mg online cheap – buy metronidazole online cheap azithromycin 500mg generic

  60. Jxmfyr Says:

    buy lasix for sale diuretic – buy prazosin generic buy capoten 25 mg generic

  61. Uucisx Says:

    order glucophage 500mg generic – order lincocin 500mg sale order lincomycin 500mg

  62. Gccklm Says:

    order clozapine 50mg for sale – order perindopril 8mg for sale order pepcid sale

  63. Mytrzo Says:

    zidovudine canada – zyloprim 300mg usa order allopurinol 100mg online cheap

Leave a Reply