Home

The Theoretical Bad-to-Worse Roadmap

June 13, 2011
9:42 am

There is a growing consensus in health policy circles that the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB), a provision of the Affordable Care Act, is an ill-conceived idea.  Empowering 15 unelected government appointees to slash Medicare spending, if expenditures exceed an arbitrary level, will likely result in lower provider payments, fewer physicians seeing Medicare patients and increased healthcare access problems for beneficiaries.  Congressional Democrats and Republicans alike are wisely urging a repeal of the IPAB provision.

In a sense, I suppose we owe thanks to the liberal-leaning Center for American Progress (CAP) think tank for showing us how a bad idea can be made dramatically worse, and why it’s urgent that IPAB repeal move forward before the concept can take effect and become entrenched in healthcare policymaking.

CAP took part in a project initiated by the Peter G. Peterson Foundation, in which several advocacy groups and research organizations were asked to present their own deficit reduction proposal.  In its plan, CAP demonstrated how IPAB can be made to resemble Godzilla with an injection of steroids. This is from pages 43 and 44 of the Peterson Foundation document:

“Our failsafe would be triggered if, starting in 2020, total economywide health care expenditures grow at a rate faster than the economy. Should that happen, we would empower the IPAB to extend successful reforms in Medicare and other public programs to insurance plans offered in the health care exchanges and then potentially to all health care plans, such that the target is met. This will ensure that costs are constrained across the health care sector, preventing cost-shifting and maintaining access for all.”

Let’s be sure to understand this.  Under this proposal, these 15 unelected bureaucrats, instead of simply having budget-cutting influence over Medicare, would have expanded domain over private health insurers and their rate negotiations with healthcare providers.  That’s a genuinely disturbing vision of the future, made more so by the fact that CAP has established itself as a valuable resource for liberal policymakers.

Anabolic steroids are prescription-only medicines that are sometimes taken without medical advice to increase muscle mass and improve athletic performance.

The statement that cost-shifting would be prevented through this expanded IPAB authority is the same Orwellian logic that says Medicare is more “efficient” than the private sector because it keeps provider reimbursements artificially low through executive fiat.  Government simply decreeing that cost shifting can’t occur is not the same as addressing the factors that lead to cost shifting.

In fact, the only logical move here is to repeal IPAB before patients and health care consumers are hurt by this kind of government “efficiency.”

66 Responses to “The Theoretical Bad-to-Worse Roadmap”

  1. Tom Maher Says:

    The one cost shift they do not seem to be concerned about is the direct cost shift to patients, who will be the ones left to pick up the tab. Of course, IPAB will not concern itself with that cost because it will represent a huge “pay for” in budget terms, which is why IPAB is such a bad idea. Blindly cutting based on a formula will not produce the intended outcomes and will ultimately harm patients.

    This is one more reason IPAB has to be repealed.

  2. Sqzjqm Says:

    generic albuterol purchase ventolin inhalator online albuterol 2mg uk

  3. Qoocvf Says:

    zanaflex pills tizanidine pill how to get tizanidine without a prescription

  4. Jekqgx Says:

    order deltasone 5mg without prescription deltasone us buy generic deltasone

  5. Zugjkr Says:

    buy generic accutane for sale isotretinoin pill isotretinoin 40mg cost

  6. Bsgeib Says:

    buy amoxicillin 250mg for sale amoxicillin order amoxicillin pills

  7. Liemmb Says:

    buy albuterol cheap order albuterol inhalator for sale order allergy pills

  8. Jltmic Says:

    generic zithromax 250mg buy cheap generic zithromax order zithromax 500mg for sale

  9. Qwvyjq Says:

    augmentin 375mg generic augmentin medication amoxiclav buy online

  10. Iirkmf Says:

    prednisolone 5mg pill prednisolone 10mg uk omnacortil 5mg price

  11. Jodkqc Says:

    levoxyl order online where to buy levothyroxine without a prescription buy synthroid 150mcg sale

  12. Uixvnn Says:

    buy gabapentin 100mg sale buy gabapentin 800mg pill buy generic neurontin 100mg

  13. Prlzim Says:

    serophene without prescription buy clomiphene 100mg for sale clomiphene for sale online

  14. Ajqxfr Says:

    buy lasix 40mg pills buy lasix 40mg generic furosemide 100mg sale

  15. Vrpqlz Says:

    generic doxycycline 100mg brand acticlate order acticlate

  16. Kqmquj Says:

    sildenafil pills 25mg sildenafil overnight shipping sildenafil order online

  17. Vwsvez Says:

    best online gambling sites online casino slots no download blackjack online for real money

  18. Sknppy Says:

    where to buy rybelsus without a prescription buy rybelsus 14mg generic cheap rybelsus 14 mg

  19. Rxfxyr Says:

    triamcinolone 10mg ca order aristocort pill buy generic triamcinolone over the counter

  20. Iezgzd Says:

    buy plaquenil without prescription cost plaquenil buy plaquenil generic

  21. Ifykpv Says:

    buy clarinex 5mg sale buy generic clarinex for sale desloratadine 5mg brand

  22. Bnewjq Says:

    cialis 10mg ca purchase tadalafil online cheap cheap tadalafil tablets

  23. Hdcvfg Says:

    loratadine 10mg uk claritin 10mg without prescription buy loratadine 10mg sale

  24. Rymfkt Says:

    oral cenforce 50mg order cenforce 100mg online how to buy cenforce

  25. Fgvrhh Says:

    buy priligy 90mg sale buy generic priligy over the counter order cytotec sale

  26. Fqqrsj Says:

    chloroquine 250mg price purchase chloroquine for sale aralen 250mg usa

  27. Cpbrcf Says:

    order orlistat 60mg online diltiazem us diltiazem us

  28. Zgjgrs Says:

    how to get glycomet without a prescription glucophage online buy buy glucophage tablets

  29. Hpvysf Says:

    zovirax 400mg ca buy zyloprim allopurinol us

  30. Nrxnan Says:

    order amlodipine 5mg without prescription norvasc 10mg without prescription order amlodipine 5mg without prescription

  31. Pvjofj Says:

    order rosuvastatin 10mg generic buy crestor generic ezetimibe order

  32. Icgrdo Says:

    lisinopril online order order lisinopril 5mg purchase lisinopril online cheap

  33. Uusulr Says:

    order generic motilium 10mg sumycin 250mg cost tetracycline 500mg pill

  34. Ttnrra Says:

    generic omeprazole order omeprazole 20mg without prescription buy generic omeprazole over the counter

  35. Jbeqhq Says:

    flexeril uk buy baclofen 25mg generic lioresal online buy

  36. Dxvyve Says:

    metoprolol cheap metoprolol uk lopressor usa

  37. Ryqxua Says:

    buy toradol 10mg colcrys uk cost gloperba

  38. Mvjcvp Says:

    atenolol 100mg cost generic atenolol buy atenolol without prescription

  39. Gipsim Says:

    purchase depo-medrol sale buy depo-medrol generic methylprednisolone 16 mg over counter

  40. Tbzzzf Says:

    buy inderal cheap cost plavix 75mg order clopidogrel without prescription

  41. Fvxouw Says:

    methotrexate 5mg for sale methotrexate 2.5mg pill buy coumadin 2mg

  42. Tzrvmo Says:

    buy custom research papers essays online to buy essay helper

  43. Heasxt Says:

    reglan 10mg pill losartan price buy cozaar sale

  44. Bmkecf Says:

    mobic 15mg brand buy celecoxib 200mg pill brand celebrex

  45. Jknopy Says:

    esomeprazole capsules buy nexium for sale topamax order online

  46. Ylnhtk Says:

    buy tamsulosin pills for sale order celecoxib 100mg without prescription celecoxib 100mg without prescription

  47. Ytphid Says:

    buy sumatriptan 25mg online cheap order levofloxacin 500mg without prescription levaquin 500mg usa

  48. Hqzubu Says:

    buy zofran 4mg for sale aldactone 25mg cheap buy aldactone 100mg generic

  49. Aipaeq Says:

    order dutasteride pills where can i buy ranitidine buy ranitidine 300mg online

  50. Hxtppx Says:

    purchase simvastatin pill buy simvastatin 20mg generic buy valtrex 1000mg pills

  51. Pozymz Says:

    buy ampicillin online cheap amoxil pills amoxicillin over the counter

  52. Vxlohh Says:

    proscar 5mg pills forcan pills order fluconazole 200mg pills

  53. Pbrzwo Says:

    buy ciprofloxacin 500mg for sale – ethambutol 600mg price purchase augmentin

  54. Bfxsyf Says:

    order cipro 500mg without prescription – oral ciprofloxacin clavulanate pills

  55. Vcbjqp Says:

    buy generic ciprofloxacin 500 mg – buy chloramphenicol erythromycin order

  56. Ndecuh Says:

    flagyl 200mg sale – clindamycin cheap purchase zithromax online

  57. Sqpcsv Says:

    ivermectine online – buy generic suprax for sale tetracycline 250mg without prescription

  58. Lxkiev Says:

    ivermectin for covid – order ciprofloxacin 500mg online oral tetracycline 250mg

  59. Xsnlfa Says:

    brand valacyclovir 500mg – starlix 120mg without prescription purchase acyclovir pill

  60. Surcry Says:

    purchase ampicillin generic buy doxycycline cheap purchase amoxil online

  61. Ydsrcw Says:

    metronidazole drug – brand cleocin 300mg azithromycin order online

  62. Ajggyo Says:

    lasix 100mg us – tacrolimus 1mg cost buy capoten 120mg without prescription

  63. Gedzir Says:

    glycomet 500mg cost – order duricef online cheap lincocin 500mg usa

  64. Qnrapj Says:

    order zidovudine 300 mg – purchase zyloprim pill

  65. Lelvqz Says:

    buy clozapine tablets – frumil 5mg brand famotidine online

  66. Yjknkr Says:

    buy seroquel pills for sale – order fluvoxamine 50mg without prescription eskalith usa

Leave a Reply