Home

Vermont and The Road Less Traveled

May 13, 2011
11:16 am

When it comes to health policy, all eyes seem to be cast toward New England these days.   The high-profile issue this week is Mitt Romney’s defense of the health reform enacted during his Massachusetts governorship and his battle with the Wall Street Journal over its merits.

I think, however, a more interesting story is developing in Vermont.

Later this month, Vermont Governor Peter Shumlin is expected to sign legislation that would, in essence, create a single-payer healthcare system in the state.  The framework of the proposed Green Mountain Care system is essentially this (it’s explained very well in a question-and-answer piece in The Washington Post):  The state would roll up all of its payers – state and local employees, Medicaid and Medicare beneficiaries, individual and small group plans – into one system, with all of the dollars received for their coverage going into Green Mountain Care, which would become the sole health payment system in the state.  Vermont will need Medicare and Medicaid waivers from the Obama Administration to make this work, as well as cooperation from the state’s largest insurer, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont, which has already declared its support (and would likely be the hands-on administrator for the new system).

Sounds neat and simple, and it’s getting raves from those who have long supported a national single-payer system, but there are some critical questions left to be answered.

First, what does Vermont do with the large employers who are self-insurers and covered under federal ERISA regulations?  One theory, expressed in the Washington Post articles, is that these employers will be taxed anyway to help pay for Green Mountain Care and, therefore, they’ll decide it’s cost-efficient to put their employees in a system they’re helping to finance.

Another question concerns the dual challenges of how to pay for a state-run single-payer system and how to contain healthcare costs to make it affordable.  Part of Vermont’s answer is the creation of a Green Mountain Care Board, sort of a revved-up version of the controversial Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB) that would have rate-setting powers for doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical products and medical devices. 

This is where Vermont’s economic and healthcare future gets a little precarious.  You see, there’s a major difference between enacting state policy and writing federal laws.  If individuals and employers believe they’re being hurt by a new state law, it’s not all that difficult to pick up stakes and move to another jurisdiction.

Will employers be open to the higher taxes that will accompany a single-payer healthcare system?  What will happen when the state has to ratchet down on physician reimbursements to keep Green Mountain Care affordable?  Will New Hampshire be the beneficiary of Vermont’s sharp swing to the left in health system transformation?

Some groups will, no doubt, judge Green Mountain Care a success if it drives private insurers out of the marketplace and replaces them with state-run healthcare.  Vermont citizens, though, may hold their judgment until they see if jobs and doctors start an exodus across the state line.

100 Responses to “Vermont and The Road Less Traveled”

  1. David N. Johnston Says:

    As an independent health insurance broker who works every day with individuals & small-medium size employers struggling to deal with rising health insurance premiums, I do understand the attraction of the Single Payer system. The basic rationale sounds airtight: “There is simply so much duplication, so much waste, so much profiteering in the private-market-based system, that if we roll it all into one big program, with one big single payer, we’ll save SO MUCH money that we can cover everyone, expand benefits, AND save money to boot!”
    The problems here, as much as single payer advocates would like them to go away, are that several consequences are utterly inevitable. Such a system WILL lead to rationing in a number of different forms: “Do we really need so many XXXXX imagining machines in one geographic area?” “Do we really need so many XXXX specialists in one geographic area?” “Why do XXXX specialists charge so much money. We should really cut that down.” These are just a few off-the-cuff examples, but you can bet they & others will come to pass.
    Additionally, simply putting single payer in place will NOT change a number of basic facts: Here in the U.S. (like all industrialized Western nations) we have an aging population that is therefore predictably consuming more healthcare; we have been born & bred to expect (demand?) the latest & greatest medical technology & newest drugs (regardless of cost), and furthermore would seem to be becoming less & less healthy every day. Simply going “single payer” cannot change these facts. Indeed, it clealy sets the stage for controls & limitations to TRY and address these issues.
    And, lastly, the cost issue. Single payer, being the perceived panacea that is, opens the door to being set up to cover a vast array of health issues that arguably may not be truly “medically necessary”. In addition to the existing cost-drivers very lightly touched upon above, these items confound an already unsustainable economic proposition. I would sincerely & respectfully recommend that all advocates of a single payer system conduct a very careful & dispationsate investigation of the vaunted Canadian system, particularly their on-going fiscal struggles. One often finds the government-run single payer system becoming the less-than-attractive default system, with a “second tier” private system being the preferred option for those that can afford it (i.e. Britain’s situation).
    Before being cast as some wild-eyed apologist for the entire private-market system, allow me to state that like all independent health insurance brokers that I know, I do believe we are in dire need of effective, intelligent, and well-designed health care reform. The National Association of Health Underwriters has developed several over the years, striving to strike a healthy balance between what the government does well, and what the private market does well.
    Bottom line: Vermont-ers, prepare yourselves for soaring costs, associated taxes & “fees”, resulting rationing, and vicious finger-pointing by all parties involved.

    David N. Johnston

  2. Zsbipi Says:

    order albuterol sale purchase albuterol inhalator generic best asthma pills

  3. Fklktk Says:

    albuterol online buy ventolin 4mg usa order ventolin inhalator generic

  4. Yzqhvo Says:

    order tizanidine 2mg generic purchase tizanidine generic buy tizanidine 2mg pills

  5. Vkeugy Says:

    buy deltasone 10mg generic prednisone over the counter deltasone price

  6. Yhdlwr Says:

    order accutane 40mg generic order generic accutane 40mg isotretinoin 10mg pill

  7. Kdxdim Says:

    order generic amoxicillin 1000mg amoxil 500mg pills amoxicillin 250mg usa

  8. Xfdyzp Says:

    albuterol buy online albuterol cheap oral ventolin

  9. Cfrpqi Says:

    ventolin where to buy albuterol 2mg brand order ventolin pills

  10. Nfwran Says:

    cheap zithromax 250mg order azithromycin 250mg pills zithromax 250mg canada

  11. Ozwfzq Says:

    cost augmentin 375mg amoxiclav sale purchase amoxiclav generic

  12. Ggpjxw Says:

    buy augmentin medication augmentin brand buy generic clavulanate online

  13. Khcnio Says:

    buy generic omnacortil over the counter buy prednisolone 5mg without prescription order omnacortil 10mg online

  14. Cybvip Says:

    cheap synthroid 150mcg buy generic levoxyl cheap generic levothroid

  15. Gneilj Says:

    purchase levothroid online synthroid 150mcg drug synthroid 150mcg ca

  16. Egrfvn Says:

    buy neurontin 800mg online order gabapentin 800mg for sale gabapentin where to buy

  17. Kqhhcn Says:

    order clomid 50mg generic purchase clomid sale order clomid 50mg pills

  18. Etabzt Says:

    buy clomiphene medication buy serophene generic order clomid online cheap

  19. Zmosis Says:

    lasix 100mg price buy furosemide pills for sale furosemide 40mg for sale

  20. Fhagmu Says:

    order sildenafil viagra mail order usa viagra 50mg brand

  21. Snhddd Says:

    cost acticlate order generic doxycycline 100mg order doxycycline 100mg

  22. Hvwfbo Says:

    genuine viagra sildenafil 100mg usa order sildenafil 50mg online

  23. Onuvbh Says:

    semaglutide where to buy rybelsus 14 mg canada order semaglutide 14mg online

  24. Papsxp Says:

    online roulette wheel online casino gambling online blackjack free

  25. Wxkjqu Says:

    order semaglutide 14 mg sale buy rybelsus 14 mg online cheap semaglutide 14 mg us

  26. Kmddaa Says:

    order hydroxychloroquine 400mg pills buy hydroxychloroquine 200mg plaquenil 200mg tablet

  27. Jrzacg Says:

    order triamcinolone 4mg buy triamcinolone sale order triamcinolone 4mg online cheap

  28. Quvslf Says:

    plaquenil price hydroxychloroquine 200mg over the counter plaquenil 400mg oral

  29. Qkbudo Says:

    buy desloratadine cheap clarinex 5mg tablet purchase desloratadine

  30. Tcacfr Says:

    usa pharmacy cialis order cialis 10mg sale cost tadalafil 20mg

  31. Owiqqy Says:

    cheap tadalafil for sale buy cialis without prescription buy tadalafil 40mg pills

  32. Cobowc Says:

    cenforce 100mg price cenforce 50mg pills order cenforce online

  33. Ihnyen Says:

    order loratadine 10mg without prescription buy loratadine 10mg without prescription claritin buy online

  34. Ljvyol Says:

    cenforce 100mg for sale cenforce 100mg cheap cenforce 100mg us

  35. Yyuiul Says:

    buy chloroquine 250mg online chloroquine cheap purchase chloroquine online cheap

  36. Osbpuy Says:

    priligy pills cytotec 200mcg without prescription misoprostol us

  37. Eilwtg Says:

    aralen pills chloroquine 250mg without prescription aralen ca

  38. Yyupoc Says:

    xenical 120mg us buy cheap diltiazem order diltiazem 180mg online cheap

  39. Ranioz Says:

    order glucophage 500mg buy glycomet cheap glycomet 1000mg usa

  40. Icgght Says:

    buy metformin 1000mg how to buy glucophage glycomet price

  41. Pdknjd Says:

    zovirax order online buy cheap generic zyloprim order zyloprim without prescription

  42. Hiiddn Says:

    norvasc 5mg cost buy amlodipine pills buy norvasc 10mg

  43. Ulseee Says:

    amlodipine 5mg pill norvasc 10mg generic brand amlodipine 5mg

  44. Mrypex Says:

    buy crestor pill order zetia 10mg online cheap zetia tablet

  45. Jtoiuj Says:

    buy zestril 5mg sale order prinivil generic order lisinopril 5mg pill

  46. Csxdqc Says:

    order lisinopril generic buy zestril 2.5mg pills zestril 10mg uk

  47. Vriqvc Says:

    buy generic domperidone over the counter motilium 10mg pill buy cheap generic sumycin

  48. Buecii Says:

    omeprazole drug omeprazole over the counter buy generic omeprazole

  49. Bfiapc Says:

    omeprazole 10mg usa purchase omeprazole pills buy prilosec 20mg pills

  50. Vzaymf Says:

    order cyclobenzaprine sale baclofen order lioresal buy online

  51. Inhbze Says:

    buy lopressor 100mg lopressor 100mg us lopressor 50mg pills

  52. Pidlox Says:

    generic lopressor 50mg order metoprolol 50mg online cheap metoprolol 50mg canada

  53. Cfwmxh Says:

    toradol cost buy ketorolac pills buy generic gloperba

  54. Dosjkl Says:

    buy tenormin 100mg online cheap tenormin ca buy tenormin 100mg generic

  55. Lmsobd Says:

    how to buy atenolol purchase tenormin generic order atenolol without prescription

  56. Hhyhxv Says:

    methylprednisolone without prescription order medrol online cheap buy medrol pill

  57. Cdbxbi Says:

    methylprednisolone 8mg over the counter order generic depo-medrol oral methylprednisolone cost

  58. Lrzlff Says:

    buy cheap inderal buy inderal online cheap clopidogrel cheap

  59. Zknlye Says:

    paper assistance online thesis writing write research paper

  60. Tcpngg Says:

    how to buy methotrexate methotrexate 5mg canada buy warfarin pill

  61. Synbrv Says:

    thesis website paper writing websites how to write my thesis

  62. Usctts Says:

    metoclopramide buy online order metoclopramide 10mg pills order cozaar online

  63. Ryebex Says:

    meloxicam 15mg for sale meloxicam 15mg cheap buy celebrex pill

  64. Acohyb Says:

    order mobic 7.5mg pills mobic order order celebrex 200mg pills

  65. Uvepxo Says:

    buy esomeprazole 40mg capsules order topiramate sale topiramate order

  66. Zuajcp Says:

    flomax usa order celebrex pill buy celecoxib for sale

  67. Vcayyr Says:

    buy tamsulosin buy flomax 0.4mg generic order celebrex for sale

  68. Fgoxyf Says:

    imitrex 25mg uk sumatriptan 50mg drug purchase levofloxacin generic

  69. Ulfeag Says:

    zofran 8mg pills spironolactone for sale online spironolactone 100mg tablet

  70. Jbpyst Says:

    buy cheap zofran zofran for sale order spironolactone sale

  71. Frrygl Says:

    buy avodart generic avodart 0.5mg without prescription zantac generic

  72. Eogndx Says:

    where to buy simvastatin without a prescription order generic simvastatin buy valtrex 500mg sale

  73. Ojcnrn Says:

    buy zocor 20mg sale zocor order order valtrex 500mg pills

  74. Iermtf Says:

    ampicillin where to buy buy acillin generic amoxil order

  75. Meolud Says:

    finasteride 5mg price order diflucan 200mg sale diflucan 200mg price

  76. Jnuoss Says:

    propecia 5mg price buy finasteride 5mg generic order diflucan 100mg online

  77. Xyuekg Says:

    ciprofloxacin price – pill myambutol 600mg cost augmentin

  78. Ftjgik Says:

    baycip online – cipro pills buy generic augmentin 625mg

  79. Gxovjo Says:

    purchase cipro for sale – oral augmentin 625mg purchase amoxiclav online cheap

  80. Pxcmuz Says:

    cipro price – augmentin 625mg oral purchase amoxiclav pills

  81. Hhzlio Says:

    ciprofloxacin 500mg pills – purchase doxycycline for sale purchase erythromycin generic

  82. Sbvlbb Says:

    order ciplox – purchase tindamax online cheap order erythromycin 500mg without prescription

  83. Osnply Says:

    buy metronidazole 200mg without prescription – buy cefaclor generic order azithromycin 500mg

  84. Yzvtoh Says:

    metronidazole 200mg generic – buy generic amoxil zithromax 250mg uk

  85. Lxbjoq Says:

    ivermectin 3 mg over the counter – order amoxiclav sale where to buy sumycin without a prescription

  86. Aqqwga Says:

    stromectol generico – ciplox 500 mg pills sumycin online

  87. Zeiffs Says:

    buy valacyclovir 500mg without prescription – valacyclovir 500mg usa buy zovirax

  88. Iujwjd Says:

    buy valtrex 1000mg – nateglinide 120mg cost buy generic zovirax for sale

  89. Lfjyyt Says:

    acillin cheap ampicillin where to buy buy amoxil generic

  90. Pftcjp Says:

    buy ampicillin paypal amoxil over the counter buy amoxicillin tablets

  91. Jvqeut Says:

    flagyl 400mg ca – amoxil pills buy zithromax 500mg online

  92. Mtblys Says:

    order metronidazole 400mg – order flagyl online cheap azithromycin 500mg over the counter

  93. Qmesol Says:

    order furosemide 40mg online cheap – capoten canada purchase capoten pills

  94. Yelymq Says:

    furosemide 100mg us – purchase lasix pills captopril tablet

  95. Ssncbr Says:

    buy glucophage pills for sale – buy bactrim generic lincomycin 500mg for sale

  96. Rskohf Says:

    buy metformin 500mg – purchase duricef online buy lincocin pill

  97. Ptfnyi Says:

    zidovudine online buy – roxithromycin 150mg us zyloprim 300mg cheap

  98. Mnkxxx Says:

    clozaril 100mg ca – frumil 5 mg cost order famotidine 40mg generic

  99. Mmpafp Says:

    clozaril 50mg over the counter – cheap altace order pepcid pill

  100. Heiopu Says:

    where to buy zidovudine without a prescription – order avapro online cheap buy allopurinol pills

Leave a Reply