Home

IPAB Dissent Disregards Party Lines

April 15, 2011
11:55 am

It’s worth noting that, in the same week that President Obama cited the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB) as a key tool in cutting future Medicare costs, a House Democrat known for her expertise on healthcare issues went public with her belief that IPAB is a bad idea that should be repealed.

In fact, Representative Allyson Schwartz (D-PA), co-chair of the New Dems Health Care Task Force, said she would support Representative Phil Roe’s legislation to do away with IPAB.  She’s not the first member of her Democratic caucus in the House to do so.  Fellow Democratic Representatives Shelley Berkley (D-NV), Michael Capuano (D-MA) and Larry Kissell (D-NC) have already cosponsored the bill.

IPAB was created by the Affordable Care Act.  The board would have the power to make Medicare spending reduction recommendations if program expenditures exceeded the per capita gross national product plus one percent.  If Congress didn’t vote down the IPAB recommendations, they would automatically take effect. In President Obama’s deficit reduction proposal, he would give IPAB even greater authority, lowering the spending threshold at which the board’s powers would kick in.

Schwartz’s reasons for opposing IPAB are good ones.  First, it transfers decisionmaking over healthcare policy from members of Congress to an unelected commission, placing an unwanted layer of bureaucracy between patients, healthcare providers and their elected representatives.  In Schwartz’s words, it would “undermine our (Congress’s) ability to represent the needs of seniors and disabled in our communities.”

She also said that she “cannot condone the implementation of a flawed policy that will risk beneficiary access to care.”

That, I believe, is the greatest knock against the IPAB concept, as it’s drawn up in the health reform law.  Rather than develop innovative ways to deliver high quality, cost effective care to Medicare beneficiaries, IPAB is simply about chopping spending levels downward.  At a time in which likely physician shortages are on the horizon, it makes little sense to “fix” Medicare by cutting payments.  As Alex Valadka, a neurosurgeon, said in National Journal, “Doctors cannot continue to ably treat Medicare patients if they are constantly wondering whether or not the money will be there to reimburse them.”

Yes, we do need to take steps to place Medicare on a sustainable course, but as Congresswoman Schwartz and others so ably point out, IPAB is the wrong tool to pursue that objective.

60 Responses to “IPAB Dissent Disregards Party Lines”

  1. Ippqdd Says:

    ventolin inhalator usa buy albuterol 2mg online order albuterol generic

  2. Nbcyze Says:

    order tizanidine 2mg pill purchase tizanidine order tizanidine sale

  3. Jsgffl Says:

    deltasone 20mg brand deltasone 20mg for sale order prednisone 20mg generic

  4. Kqbznz Says:

    purchase absorica pill isotretinoin 20mg generic brand accutane

  5. Ytnxty Says:

    amoxicillin 250mg cheap amoxil brand where can i buy amoxicillin

  6. Hrshyf Says:

    buy augmentin 375mg pill augmentin over the counter augmentin 625mg tablet

  7. Zmpwvz Says:

    order azithromycin order zithromax 250mg zithromax sale

  8. Hynzdf Says:

    order synthroid pill levothroid oral purchase levoxyl pills

  9. Phvbmu Says:

    cheap prednisolone 10mg order prednisolone 40mg sale omnacortil medication

  10. Jarpvz Says:

    order clomiphene 100mg clomiphene cheap clomid 100mg us

  11. Cojkcg Says:

    cheap gabapentin online neurontin tablets purchase neurontin

  12. Xevnti Says:

    sildenafil pills sildenafil pills 100mg buy generic sildenafil 100mg

  13. Cxohwr Says:

    buy furosemide for sale diuretic lasix 100mg pills order furosemide 100mg online

  14. Xshudj Says:

    buy rybelsus 14 mg generic order generic semaglutide 14 mg order rybelsus 14 mg sale

  15. Znwdux Says:

    vibra-tabs pills buy generic acticlate buy doxycycline 200mg online

  16. Qgctuq Says:

    generic aristocort buy triamcinolone for sale triamcinolone without prescription

  17. Vnmyuk Says:

    cost cialis 10mg buy generic cialis 20mg cheap cialis pill

  18. Bqrhff Says:

    desloratadine 5mg pill desloratadine brand clarinex 5mg tablet

  19. Eihiwc Says:

    buy loratadine generic order loratadine order loratadine generic

  20. Lnumpm Says:

    cheap aralen buy cheap chloroquine buy generic aralen

  21. Dfgrhh Says:

    brand dapoxetine dapoxetine 60mg without prescription purchase misoprostol online cheap

  22. Cfxyvs Says:

    glucophage where to buy buy glucophage 1000mg online glycomet without prescription

  23. Gyhytj Says:

    buy orlistat online cheap orlistat 120mg for sale buy diltiazem no prescription

  24. Sitknf Says:

    buy generic lipitor order atorvastatin 80mg generic lipitor 20mg drug

  25. Ivkzca Says:

    norvasc 10mg drug generic amlodipine 5mg amlodipine 10mg sale

  26. Zyhinu Says:

    buy acyclovir 400mg generic zyloprim 300mg ca order allopurinol sale

  27. Ucmich Says:

    lisinopril for sale generic lisinopril 5mg zestril sale

  28. Bolbmb Says:

    buy crestor 10mg online cheap order generic zetia purchase ezetimibe online

  29. Scxsba Says:

    buy generic omeprazole over the counter buy prilosec online prilosec 20mg for sale

  30. Xnxltt Says:

    order domperidone pill tetracycline canada oral tetracycline 500mg

  31. Yutgpx Says:

    lopressor uk order lopressor 100mg for sale where to buy lopressor without a prescription

  32. Jufdhx Says:

    order flexeril 15mg pill purchase flexeril sale order baclofen 10mg online

  33. Qcdlsw Says:

    buy tenormin 100mg sale tenormin over the counter atenolol 100mg brand

  34. Srgujx Says:

    ketorolac sale purchase colchicine pill colcrys without prescription

  35. Tjaxmn Says:

    medrol 16mg over counter buy methylprednisolone without a prescription buy medrol 16mg online

  36. Hsdivf Says:

    assignment website write my term paper buy assignments

  37. Vqemrx Says:

    inderal 10mg us generic inderal 20mg buy clopidogrel online

  38. Jdirqb Says:

    methotrexate 5mg usa coumadin 5mg over the counter warfarin 2mg without prescription

  39. Ichcao Says:

    mobic brand order celecoxib online celebrex 100mg price

  40. Yfjagg Says:

    reglan us buy generic reglan over the counter buy losartan pills for sale

  41. Ytkyic Says:

    tamsulosin 0.2mg pills generic celebrex celecoxib for sale online

  42. Lwlwey Says:

    nexium 40mg oral purchase esomeprazole sale topiramate order

  43. Ilepjz Says:

    brand zofran 4mg zofran over the counter spironolactone price

  44. Gnjbil Says:

    purchase sumatriptan without prescription order imitrex 25mg without prescription levofloxacin 250mg drug

  45. Suojob Says:

    buy simvastatin pill valtrex 500mg tablet valtrex tablet

  46. Jdeogn Says:

    avodart medication zantac 300mg over the counter zantac 300mg brand

  47. Egmrpq Says:

    acillin generic buy generic amoxicillin online amoxil cost

  48. Vmesrl Says:

    brand finasteride diflucan oral buy forcan cheap

  49. Pkyafw Says:

    baycip over the counter – cephalexin uk augmentin 625mg uk

  50. Ypbtef Says:

    purchase cipro sale – sulfamethoxazole oral buy augmentin cheap

  51. Njacgr Says:

    order flagyl 400mg – order cleocin 300mg sale cost azithromycin 500mg

  52. Cyriyb Says:

    order generic ciprofloxacin 500 mg – ciprofloxacin over the counter oral erythromycin

  53. Pdmzmv Says:

    buy generic valtrex for sale – nemasole without prescription buy acyclovir 400mg pills

  54. Axxkqm Says:

    ivermectin 6mg without a doctor prescription – buy amoxiclav pills for sale order sumycin 500mg pill

  55. Nsvvfp Says:

    flagyl ca – cleocin cheap buy azithromycin 250mg

  56. Hkigso Says:

    ampicillin for sale online oral penicillin buy amoxicillin no prescription

  57. Xgrwem Says:

    buy furosemide sale – order prazosin generic how to buy capoten

  58. Abtsof Says:

    buy glycomet online – purchase lamivudine online buy lincocin 500 mg without prescription

  59. Bmsjkj Says:

    retrovir online order – order avapro 300mg pill order zyloprim 100mg generic

  60. Zbuxef Says:

    cost clozapine 100mg – buy amaryl tablets order pepcid sale

Leave a Reply