Home

The Deficit Commission and Healthcare

November 11, 2010
4:37 pm

jp-fiscal-articlelargeThe Washington Post and New York Times are ablaze today with top-of-the-page headlines about the proposals being made by the co-chairs of President Obama’s bipartisan commission on deficit reduction.  There may be a bit of an overreaction to the draft report since there’s no assurance it will receive the necessary support of 14 (out of 18) commission members, and Congress is under no obligation whatsoever to adopt the proposals.

Nonetheless, the commission co-chairs Erskine Bowles, former chief of staff to President Clinton, and former U.S. Senator Alan Simpson deserve credit for taking on the tough task of trying to curb the nation’s burgeoning red ink.  Their report doesn’t hesitate to put some political sacred cows on the chopping block in the name of deficit reduction.

The healthcare provisions of the co-chairs’ proposals illustrate the difficulty in trying to reconcile two very important goals Americans want to see achieved – reducing deficit spending and improving our U.S. healthcare system.  The Bowles-Simpson report illustrates how difficult it is to achieve one without potentially undermining the other.

For example, the draft report calls for the creation of a public health insurance option, a policy notion that Congress soundly rejected in the health reform debate.  As we’ve discussed ad nauseum, a public option will certainly drive down payment rates to physicians and hospitals, but those costs would then be shifted to private payers.  And a public option with arbitrarily-low costs would reduce the amount of competition in the insurance marketplace, a development that wouldn’t serve consumers well.

The report calls for strengthening the Independent Payment Advisory Board to an even greater degree than called for in the new health reform law.  This would create an even more potent entity in terms of simply axing healthcare spending, but without a focus on how to elevate healthcare value.

The report says doctors and other health providers will have to be paid less.   At the same time, we’re faced with the need to recruit more people into the medical profession to deal with the tens of millions of newly-insured Americans entering the system. 

Yes, there is an urgent need to address the nation’s rising deficits, and the health sector has to do its part.  But, understanding the challenges we’re facing in the years ahead, with one in every three Americans expected to have diabetes by the year 2040 and other chronic diseases on the rise, we have to look at the healthcare system as more than just numbers on a balance sheet.   

Work needs to accelerate on delivery reform, on payment reform, on changing the tort system (which, to their credit, the commission co-chairs recommend) to reduce defensive medicine costs, on attacking the chronic diseases that account for 75 cents of every health dollar we spend. 

But deficit reduction and quality healthcare should not be treated as an either-or choice.  The commission’s work is an essential exercise in numbers, but we can’t forget the real patients and consumers who would be affected.

102 Responses to “The Deficit Commission and Healthcare”

  1. LillyPad | Deficit Commission and the Potential Impact to IPAB Says:

    [...] deficit commission’s draft report even recommended strengthening IPAB.  Prognosis: A Healthcare Blog, discusses the recommended strengthening of IPAB, “The report calls for strengthening the Independent Payment Advisory Board to an even greater [...]

  2. Enqvxk Says:

    albuterol pills order ventolin 4mg generic buy allergy pills

  3. Kqisla Says:

    best allergy medicine for adults order albuterol inhalator without prescription albuterol order

  4. Lkpsqc Says:

    order tizanidine generic oral tizanidine oral tizanidine 2mg

  5. Arwrgm Says:

    prednisone 5mg pills order deltasone online how to buy prednisone

  6. Samyzq Says:

    buy isotretinoin 40mg without prescription isotretinoin 10mg canada accutane 40mg uk

  7. Sfjoag Says:

    purchase albuterol generic generic asthma pills ventolin inhalator order online

  8. Ernufg Says:

    how to buy albuterol albuterol inhaler albuterol inhalator us

  9. Ethrxq Says:

    buy amoxicillin pills order amoxil 250mg amoxil 250mg over the counter

  10. Qmmrrn Says:

    buy clavulanate tablets purchase amoxiclav online buy augmentin medication

  11. Bowzef Says:

    augmentin online buy buy clavulanate tablets augmentin 625mg ca

  12. Rlfvzh Says:

    zithromax 500mg over the counter order azithromycin 250mg online buy generic zithromax

  13. Gwncts Says:

    levoxyl medication order levothyroxine levoxyl cheap

  14. Ujycio Says:

    levothyroxine generic buy levothroid for sale buy levothroid generic

  15. Foxvim Says:

    omnacortil medication order prednisolone 10mg pill omnacortil 10mg canada

  16. Uqckei Says:

    clomiphene 100mg pills clomiphene 50mg for sale order clomiphene 100mg

  17. Oiodyo Says:

    order clomid 50mg sale generic clomid 100mg buy clomiphene 50mg pill

  18. Zhsxfk Says:

    buy gabapentin 600mg sale order gabapentin 600mg pills order gabapentin 800mg sale

  19. Mvakyx Says:

    purchase furosemide online furosemide 40mg over the counter furosemide price

  20. Kzxqlk Says:

    buy sildenafil 50mg generic viagra sildenafil 25mg viagra 50mg oral

  21. Yqwjac Says:

    sildenafil medication sildenafil mail order cheap sildenafil

  22. Lemwgw Says:

    doxycycline us order doxycycline 200mg pills buy doxycycline medication

  23. Ovqaag Says:

    buy generic rybelsus online cost rybelsus 14mg rybelsus 14mg sale

  24. Cluwqq Says:

    semaglutide pills buy rybelsus 14 mg online cheap order rybelsus 14 mg for sale

  25. Yevppj Says:

    plaquenil 400mg for sale plaquenil 200mg over the counter order generic plaquenil 200mg

  26. Pzydqs Says:

    buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg pill buy hydroxychloroquine 400mg hydroxychloroquine medication

  27. Kpxsue Says:

    aristocort 4mg pill order triamcinolone 4mg online purchase triamcinolone online

  28. Oneaoy Says:

    cialis usa cialis generic name cialis ca

  29. Vudwrs Says:

    female cialis tadalafil max dose order tadalafil 10mg without prescription

  30. Dyamnf Says:

    clarinex 5mg canada buy clarinex 5mg online desloratadine 5mg cost

  31. Aoekyx Says:

    cenforce drug cenforce where to buy cenforce generic

  32. Jwoziv Says:

    buy cenforce paypal cenforce 100mg tablet buy generic cenforce online

  33. Wrqruc Says:

    purchase loratadine for sale claritin 10mg tablet buy loratadine generic

  34. Eqwckn Says:

    aralen usa cost aralen 250mg where can i buy chloroquine

  35. Swsrml Says:

    chloroquine 250mg tablet order chloroquine online chloroquine price

  36. Wqhlui Says:

    buy generic dapoxetine 60mg misoprostol 200mcg usa cheap misoprostol

  37. Ulcidm Says:

    buy glycomet pills for sale generic metformin 500mg glucophage 1000mg pills

  38. Lswdrk Says:

    buy generic glucophage over the counter order glucophage 1000mg online glycomet uk

  39. Kqneko Says:

    metformin sale purchase glucophage online cheap glucophage 1000mg over the counter

  40. Vhflgz Says:

    orlistat 60mg cost xenical 60mg for sale buy diltiazem 180mg without prescription

  41. Qfnwov Says:

    buy atorvastatin online cheap lipitor ca buy lipitor generic

  42. Bhsnli Says:

    cost norvasc 5mg buy norvasc no prescription order norvasc generic

  43. Yzcsoi Says:

    norvasc 5mg tablet order amlodipine 10mg generic order amlodipine 5mg

  44. Tbzuqo Says:

    order acyclovir 800mg generic purchase zovirax online cheap order zyloprim 100mg generic

  45. Buaazx Says:

    zestril 10mg cost buy generic lisinopril 10mg zestril pill

  46. Pnkplr Says:

    lisinopril 10mg canada order lisinopril without prescription purchase prinivil without prescription

  47. Akxzzv Says:

    crestor 10mg without prescription rosuvastatin 20mg cost buy generic zetia over the counter

  48. Qxchaz Says:

    omeprazole us prilosec uk buy omeprazole 10mg for sale

  49. Xlnsig Says:

    prilosec 20mg pills buy prilosec 10mg without prescription order prilosec pills

  50. Ikvyxx Says:

    cost motilium motilium 10mg tablet tetracycline 500mg without prescription

  51. Dciiqf Says:

    buy lopressor 50mg for sale buy metoprolol sale order metoprolol pill

  52. Qydwnh Says:

    lopressor order online lopressor pills lopressor for sale

  53. Cgpjce Says:

    cyclobenzaprine cost cyclobenzaprine 15mg usa buy baclofen 10mg generic

  54. Kpvujr Says:

    buy atenolol without prescription order atenolol online order atenolol 50mg generic

  55. Rgwzmf Says:

    toradol usa order colcrys 0.5mg online colcrys pills

  56. Znppsr Says:

    buy tenormin 50mg tenormin where to buy purchase tenormin online

  57. Ybyqkm Says:

    buy depo-medrol tablets buy medrol 16mg can i buy methylprednisolone online

  58. Jfqtsv Says:

    buy medrol pills for sale methylprednisolone 8mg otc methylprednisolone pills canada

  59. Vejjnl Says:

    online essay writing buy thesis paper buy thesis paper

  60. Cdiozk Says:

    inderal tablet clopidogrel 75mg tablet order clopidogrel 75mg pills

  61. Bbzwsh Says:

    need a paper written best essay writers online i need help with my assignment

  62. Gssvya Says:

    methotrexate 5mg cheap cost methotrexate warfarin 2mg price

  63. Mxrvax Says:

    mobic 15mg us order celebrex online cheap celebrex medication

  64. Xnqpju Says:

    order meloxicam 15mg online cheap celebrex tablet buy generic celecoxib

  65. Embpdr Says:

    order generic metoclopramide purchase maxolon buy cozaar 25mg sale

  66. Dewimo Says:

    tamsulosin 0.4mg oral flomax cheap cost celecoxib

  67. Lfdpro Says:

    order flomax generic celebrex 100mg pills celecoxib 200mg pills

  68. Twadcw Says:

    esomeprazole 20mg pills order topiramate 100mg without prescription where can i buy topamax

  69. Aoobvb Says:

    buy zofran online spironolactone 25mg cost spironolactone 25mg drug

  70. Hxfcis Says:

    buy zofran pills for sale purchase aldactone for sale spironolactone price

  71. Jjylyn Says:

    buy sumatriptan online cheap buy imitrex 50mg for sale levofloxacin cost

  72. Uuenqt Says:

    buy zocor 20mg generic order valacyclovir 1000mg online cheap order valacyclovir 1000mg generic

  73. Tkspmt Says:

    buy simvastatin 20mg without prescription simvastatin 10mg pills oral valacyclovir 1000mg

  74. Kxnqls Says:

    avodart 0.5mg over the counter ranitidine 300mg drug ranitidine 300mg usa

  75. Mxzmgl Says:

    buy proscar sale propecia 5mg sale diflucan 200mg without prescription

  76. Frmgot Says:

    buy generic ampicillin online amoxil order online purchase amoxicillin

  77. Dvwlyj Says:

    purchase proscar online propecia 5mg ca buy cheap generic fluconazole

  78. Cateqa Says:

    buy cipro 500mg online cheap – buy keflex generic order augmentin 1000mg sale

  79. Qepwwt Says:

    order ciprofloxacin 500mg generic – order cephalexin 500mg online cheap amoxiclav over the counter

  80. Ddwhji Says:

    order ciprofloxacin 500mg online – buy keflex sale augmentin 375mg oral

  81. Kcdfoq Says:

    cipro 1000mg over the counter – keflex 250mg price buy clavulanate no prescription

  82. Ckabod Says:

    buy metronidazole 400mg pill – order azithromycin purchase zithromax generic

  83. Sotoey Says:

    ciprofloxacin medication – amoxicillin without prescription
    erythromycin 500mg generic

  84. Ibgaqy Says:

    buy flagyl 400mg for sale – order azithromycin 250mg without prescription azithromycin uk

  85. Cjckva Says:

    order ciplox 500 mg pills – buy amoxicillin pills for sale
    buy erythromycin 250mg without prescription

  86. Sdqtdr Says:

    valacyclovir 1000mg cheap – nemasole order online zovirax 400mg cheap

  87. Hdiysa Says:

    generic ivermectin for humans – order ciplox 500mg sale sumycin canada

  88. Oinyou Says:

    order valtrex 1000mg generic – purchase diltiazem without prescription order zovirax generic

  89. Benaig Says:

    ivermectin over counter – tetracycline 500mg generic sumycin 250mg brand

  90. Rmztpn Says:

    buy metronidazole 200mg generic – cefaclor canada purchase azithromycin sale

  91. Msxeuw Says:

    buy acillin generic ampicillin for sale order amoxil generic

  92. Poihhl Says:

    flagyl 200mg canada – buy amoxicillin pills azithromycin canada

  93. Fzbvau Says:

    order furosemide 40mg – capoten over the counter order capoten for sale

  94. Uoauhj Says:

    purchase ampicillin without prescription cheap amoxil generic purchase amoxil generic

  95. Qaxrmd Says:

    order furosemide pills – coumadin 2mg cost capoten pill

  96. Wkjtij Says:

    buy glycomet no prescription – cheap cipro buy lincomycin without a prescription

  97. Spvzac Says:

    purchase zidovudine online pill – order zyloprim 300mg generic cost allopurinol 300mg

  98. Jytpsu Says:

    buy retrovir 300 mg online – rulide 150 mg uk buy allopurinol for sale

  99. Jmordn Says:

    glucophage oral – buy septra no prescription purchase lincomycin for sale

  100. Agvuop Says:

    clozapine cost – order glimepiride for sale pepcid over the counter

  101. Wgldbe Says:

    seroquel tablet – order trazodone 50mg for sale buy eskalith paypal

  102. Zzlsye Says:

    clozaril order – frumil usa brand famotidine 40mg

Leave a Reply