Home

Babies, Bathwater and the “Repeal and Replace” Message

October 14, 2010
1:04 pm

I’m not going to wade into partisan politics here because the Healthcare Leadership Council has a long-standing policy against endorsing political candidates.  I am concerned, though, about the “repeal and replace” message, relating to health reform, that a number of candidates are using as a focal point for their campaigns.

First, we can say with virtual certainty that repeal of the Affordable Care Act isn’t going to happen.  Not only does the President still have veto power, but it is also highly unlikely that repeal legislation could muster 60 votes to get through the U.S. Senate.

But beyond the political realities, there’s also a question as to whether it’s an effective message or even the right thing to do.

Bill McInturff of Public Opinion Strategies, one of the nation’s premiere experts when it comes to collecting and analyzing public opinion, made some excellent points on this subject in an interview with Marilyn Werber Serafini that appeared in both The Washington Post and Kaiser Health News.  McInturff argues that it’s not logical to insist that all facets of the new health reform law is bad.

He said, “If you’re for repeal and replace, it means you have to say that every single element of health care is something you disagree with, or at least allows your opponent to characterize your position that way.  That seems to me to not make much sense.  Number two, people are conscious that we fought for a year about this.  And so telling people that we’re going to start totally from scratch and do it again, there’s a certain kind of weariness about the process.”

Even if repeal of health reform was a feasible possibility, would Americans really want to roll back assistance for small businesses to help provide private health coverage for their employees, or new measures to help more people get preventive care and reduce the chronic disease costs that drive health spending skyward? 

The fact is that health reform does need to be revisited.  The measure passed by Congress, among other flaws, isn’t strong enough in its delivery reform and payment reform aspects and relies too heavily on the Medicaid program to reduce the uninsured rolls.  But we don’t want to throw out the important progress that has already been achieved and, as McInturff assets, it’s not a particularly effective message to say that we should.

100 Responses to “Babies, Bathwater and the “Repeal and Replace” Message”

  1. Mike Sullivan Says:

    Mary,
    Your comments are a simple and straightforward as they are logical. Thanks for a dispassionate take on the situation at hand. Health care reform is an amazingly complex issue. My view is that the bill, albeit having nothing to do with controlling costs (as it was sold to the public,) is at least a starting point that has providers, insurers and most other stakeholders (except trial lawyers) at the table preparing for change. My view is that our focus should be on improving core elements of the bill, not focusing on pure politics as usual in America.

  2. Cdjmkt Says:

    buy generic ventolin 2mg albuterol 2mg pill purchase ventolin inhalator generic

  3. Vpudcx Says:

    generic allergy pills buy cheap generic ventolin buy ventolin inhaler

  4. Mutcvr Says:

    order tizanidine online order tizanidine 2mg for sale buy cheap zanaflex

  5. Ncxgwb Says:

    buy deltasone 40mg pills order deltasone 10mg prednisone 10mg for sale

  6. Huitps Says:

    order accutane 40mg generic cost isotretinoin 10mg order accutane 20mg

  7. Xfhzno Says:

    ventolin usa order albuterol inhaler ventolin 4mg cheap

  8. Dhlpfz Says:

    purchase albuterol online cheap albuterol 2mg drug albuterol inhalator order

  9. Uynvji Says:

    buy amoxicillin no prescription cost amoxil 250mg buy amoxicillin 250mg generic

  10. Vqmgos Says:

    how to get augmentin without a prescription augmentin 1000mg over the counter brand amoxiclav

  11. Rjqcob Says:

    clavulanate for sale oral augmentin buy augmentin 625mg pills

  12. Fvvold Says:

    cheap zithromax 250mg azithromycin pill order zithromax without prescription

  13. Pdpfqv Says:

    levothyroxine order online purchase levothroid without prescription buy levoxyl pill

  14. Wzskvp Says:

    buy synthroid without prescription synthroid us synthroid 75mcg canada

  15. Iltkir Says:

    order prednisolone 5mg online cheap prednisolone 40mg for sale buy omnacortil 5mg generic

  16. Eskmhb Says:

    clomiphene 50mg usa generic clomiphene buy clomiphene 100mg online cheap

  17. Pgzgje Says:

    buy clomiphene 50mg online cheap order clomiphene 50mg without prescription serophene sale

  18. Nkahpw Says:

    buy gabapentin 600mg without prescription order neurontin 600mg for sale neurontin oral

  19. Ugtspi Says:

    viagra 50mg canada sildenafil pills 25mg buy sildenafil 100mg pills

  20. Fuoqlv Says:

    purchase sildenafil pills sildenafil 50mg sale usa viagra sales

  21. Cjlpka Says:

    generic lasix 40mg furosemide 40mg without prescription oral furosemide 100mg

  22. Kykkpv Says:

    order rybelsus 14 mg online rybelsus price order semaglutide 14mg generic

  23. Japrio Says:

    order rybelsus 14mg buy rybelsus cheap order generic rybelsus 14 mg

  24. Ovsdos Says:

    order monodox sale purchase vibra-tabs generic purchase acticlate sale

  25. Uedrcy Says:

    hydroxychloroquine 200mg sale purchase hydroxychloroquine sale plaquenil 400mg without prescription

  26. Nnubdb Says:

    triamcinolone ca order aristocort 4mg online aristocort 10mg pills

  27. Kpqfoj Says:

    tadalafil india buy tadalafil pills cialis order online

  28. Jjfgrk Says:

    buy tadalafil 20mg sale buy tadalafil online cheap cialis overnight shipping

  29. Zytvrs Says:

    order clarinex sale order desloratadine generic desloratadine 5mg oral

  30. Nfjuhf Says:

    cenforce 100mg tablet buy cenforce 50mg for sale order generic cenforce 100mg

  31. Hvmeht Says:

    cenforce sale order cenforce buy cenforce 100mg

  32. Kvubho Says:

    chloroquine drug chloroquine medication aralen 250mg tablet

  33. Mussez Says:

    loratadine drug claritin over the counter order loratadine generic

  34. Rwbrta Says:

    buy cheap generic aralen buy aralen paypal buy chloroquine 250mg pill

  35. Alvtkk Says:

    order metformin 1000mg for sale buy glycomet 1000mg generic glycomet 500mg sale

  36. Hwgutf Says:

    order generic dapoxetine priligy 60mg us cytotec over the counter

  37. Pnuiwh Says:

    order metformin 1000mg online glucophage 500mg pills metformin cost

  38. Qqmqbg Says:

    metformin uk order metformin 500mg pill order glycomet pill

  39. Uerbnf Says:

    oral orlistat diltiazem 180mg tablet buy diltiazem generic

  40. Rdjwsd Says:

    atorvastatin 10mg brand cheap lipitor 10mg atorvastatin tablet

  41. Jjaazc Says:

    cheap lipitor 20mg atorvastatin 80mg usa order atorvastatin 10mg generic

  42. Foybpv Says:

    amlodipine 10mg usa norvasc uk purchase amlodipine generic

  43. Iscctx Says:

    order norvasc generic amlodipine cost amlodipine 10mg for sale

  44. Vhfymp Says:

    order acyclovir 400mg online cheap order zovirax online cost zyloprim

  45. Htxaid Says:

    buy zestril online cheap lisinopril 2.5mg pill buy zestril generic

  46. Dppbpx Says:

    order prinivil generic zestril 2.5mg drug prinivil for sale online

  47. Ueayhr Says:

    order rosuvastatin for sale where to buy zetia without a prescription order generic zetia

  48. Ndprxc Says:

    buy cheap prilosec buy omeprazole 20mg pill buy prilosec 20mg online cheap

  49. Qpytsu Says:

    omeprazole to treat esophagus omeprazole price buy generic omeprazole

  50. Hetgag Says:

    buy motilium sale buy sumycin 500mg sumycin 500mg usa

  51. Omsnhz Says:

    metoprolol 100mg brand buy lopressor medication buy generic lopressor

  52. Cozfpc Says:

    lopressor 100mg for sale buy metoprolol 100mg online purchase metoprolol for sale

  53. Tgxggb Says:

    flexeril online buy ozobax paypal lioresal online

  54. Sjtqet Says:

    brand atenolol 100mg tenormin 50mg cost tenormin order

  55. Bmkmsa Says:

    atenolol 50mg for sale cheap tenormin 50mg order tenormin 100mg generic

  56. Lmvfrz Says:

    ketorolac over the counter buy colcrys 0.5mg without prescription buy generic colcrys 0.5mg

  57. Ctplwu Says:

    methylprednisolone brand name buy depo-medrol online cheap buy methylprednisolone medication

  58. Dwmhjw Says:

    buy generic medrol over the counter methylprednisolone 16 mg without a doctor prescription buy depo-medrol

  59. Gjkcpu Says:

    buy an assignment best essay writing websites custom dissertation

  60. Rdxqww Says:

    academic writing service editing essays need help writing a paper

  61. Letchl Says:

    oral propranolol cheap clopidogrel purchase clopidogrel without prescription

  62. Klsmwc Says:

    buy methotrexate 10mg sale warfarin pills warfarin canada

  63. Fosevq Says:

    cost meloxicam 7.5mg celebrex generic buy celebrex no prescription

  64. Wzmffh Says:

    meloxicam oral order celebrex 100mg pill brand celecoxib 200mg

  65. Rtfprd Says:

    purchase metoclopramide sale hyzaar uk losartan online buy

  66. Eynefc Says:

    tamsulosin 0.2mg cheap tamsulosin 0.2mg pill purchase celecoxib pills

  67. Fxvpza Says:

    flomax 0.2mg generic tamsulosin oral celebrex 200mg usa

  68. Ysqdkv Says:

    nexium 20mg pills topiramate 100mg without prescription buy topiramate 100mg online cheap

  69. Hvasxc Says:

    buy zofran 4mg pills ondansetron 8mg ca order aldactone 100mg pills

  70. Faoqhc Says:

    ondansetron price buy aldactone 25mg sale brand spironolactone 100mg

  71. Qvktyv Says:

    imitrex uk imitrex where to buy oral levaquin 500mg

  72. Bfeykw Says:

    buy zocor online valacyclovir 1000mg tablet valtrex 1000mg uk

  73. Txdxqd Says:

    buy generic avodart for sale buy zantac 150mg online cheap oral zantac 300mg

  74. Kgbsrv Says:

    order ampicillin without prescription cheap amoxil generic order amoxil sale

  75. Nzfwux Says:

    order proscar 1mg sale buy propecia 1mg without prescription order forcan online

  76. Pueaxo Says:

    proscar over the counter proscar without prescription buy diflucan pills for sale

  77. Nbuztw Says:

    order generic cipro – ciprofloxacin 1000mg generic amoxiclav canada

  78. Ngnbqz Says:

    buy ciprofloxacin online – myambutol 600mg for sale cheap augmentin 375mg

  79. Nsofbp Says:

    buy generic baycip for sale – cephalexin 250mg without prescription clavulanate generic

  80. Ptmard Says:

    cipro 500mg generic – purchase septra pills order augmentin 625mg online

  81. Crqvlq Says:

    buy metronidazole generic – buy cefaclor 250mg generic order zithromax 500mg generic

  82. Rmzfdv Says:

    buy flagyl no prescription – generic cefaclor 500mg buy zithromax 500mg for sale

  83. Vozoyq Says:

    buy ciprofloxacin 500mg – buy chloramphenicol pill purchase erythromycin for sale

  84. Qgdreg Says:

    order ciplox without prescription – erythromycin 500mg us erythromycin oral

  85. Tetauh Says:

    buy generic valacyclovir 500mg – order valtrex for sale buy acyclovir 400mg pills

  86. Wfhgft Says:

    buy valtrex paypal – cheap nemasole for sale acyclovir 400mg ca

  87. Clyvsy Says:

    buy ivermectin for humans – purchase tetracycline pill cost sumycin 250mg

  88. Uqfsbb Says:

    ivermectin tablet – aczone for sale online order tetracycline 250mg sale

  89. Cwmybm Says:

    metronidazole 200mg usa – buy cheap metronidazole azithromycin 500mg tablet

  90. Ggurrw Says:

    order flagyl generic – cheap amoxicillin pills buy azithromycin 250mg generic

  91. Pfeswx Says:

    buy acillin generic ampicillin cost amoxil cost

  92. Stwaqb Says:

    buy ampicillin without a prescription vibra-tabs cost purchase amoxicillin without prescription

  93. Etcaon Says:

    buy lasix 100mg sale – tacrolimus price buy capoten 25 mg

  94. Ycbwwk Says:

    furosemide 40mg without prescription – tacrolimus ca captopril 25mg oral

  95. Vqsvat Says:

    cost glycomet 1000mg – metformin 500mg brand cheap lincomycin

  96. Lnjvah Says:

    purchase retrovir generic – buy generic glycomet for sale order generic allopurinol

  97. Qerbyy Says:

    metformin drug – order duricef 250mg sale order lincocin 500mg sale

  98. Uwpmjd Says:

    buy zidovudine generic – purchase avapro pills allopurinol uk

  99. Adofhg Says:

    buy generic clozaril for sale – order glimepiride pill famotidine 40mg cost

  100. Debblc Says:

    cost clozaril – buy generic famotidine brand pepcid

Leave a Reply